Three Threats to Asia’s Urban Heritage

4573943452_b60b5be922_z

This post is also available in: Chinese (Traditional)

Asia’s urban heritage faces unique challenges. As you read this, the International Council on Monuments and Sites has recently finished a conference in Phuket Town, Thailand, tackling the subject of ‘Asian Urban Heritage’. During this conference the strong will to protect the history of Asian countries was discussed, as were three threats: natural disasters, differing concepts of heritage and pressure from urbanization.

Natural Disasters 

Recent natural disasters have drawn attention to the way that heritage assets are managed during emergency periods.  Tsunamis, hurricanes, mudslides and fires all have an impact on historic structures and landscapes, and can leave permanent damage. This is especially true in urban areas where emergency resources are directed towards essential services and rebuilding.

Intangible Heritage 

Current conservation practices in Western countries rely heavily on physical retention and restoration of built heritage, whereas, Eastern or Asian heritage preservation has a strong focus on the intangible heritage. Intangible Heritage as defined by the Heritage Centre for Asia and the Pacific is “intangible objects, especially expressions of a community’s culture such as language, religion, oral histories folk stories, song and dances, traditional crafts and building skills”. This type of heritage is correspondingly harder to protect, as its continuation lies with the population to continue cultural practices and to convey and actively participate in the spirit or “genius loci” of a place.

Rapid Urbanization 

Urban areas in Asia are under enormous pressure to industrialize and maximize their economic potential. Cities are expanding to accommodate the emigration of people, causing a swell in the urban population. In the 1970s Asia had eight major cities of five million or more people, now there are more than thirty. Sudden urbanization requires the rapid building of infrastructure and services. However, since this urban development is fairly recent in many cases there are inadequate heritage guidelines. This means significant heritage places may be overlooked and compromised. Several city centers have been declared heritage areas to overcome this problem, including Georgetown in Penang, Malaysia which is now a World Heritage Site.

Images courtesy of Arthur Chapman, Viajar and Christopher Chan on flickr

  • http://twitter.com/ULGlobalCities Annick Labeca

    It is however important to add another aspect that Asian cities will face: climate change. You have enumated three threats to Asia’s Urban Heritage: Natural disasters, intangible heritage and rapid urbanization. But, what about climate change? I am not sure that it is good to consider global warming as one aspect of natural disasters. Tsunami and earthquake are not due to climate change. 
    In this case, recent Bangkok flooding is the impact of various factors, let’s mention them: from rapid urbanization to climate change. Let’s take the case of Japan which recently suffered from natural disasters earthquake and tsunami. It is clear that not only natural disasters will continue to have a strong impact on Asian urban areas (Japan just released a 10-year plan to demolish wooden buildings in particular in overcrowded areas such as residential areas to protect residents from damaged that may be caused by earthquake) but also climate change. It is difficult to draw a list of consequences that will affect this region — lack of freshwater, flooding (which will particularly concern coastal cities), droughts, etc. — but we know that Asian cities must include climate change (but also other risks such as viruses to quote but a few, viruses which will surely continue to affect cities such as recent SARS virus that affected cities in 2003) to enable adaptation to environmental constraints. I hope to have been clear due to the fact English is not my mother tongue…